Presentation Buddy
A quiet room for words that want to travel.
Skip to content
Presentation Buddy
Presentation Buddy
Science · Public lecture

The Beautiful Failure of the Mars Lander

On the value of a hypothesis that dies cleanly, and why engineers should grieve their instruments out loud.

Feb 14, 20263 min read365 words
#science#failure#curiosity
Reading
100%

It failed at 2,340 metres

Our lander died 2,340 metres above the . It did not crash in a . It did something much sadder: it worked right up until the moment one number, on one by one tired person, with another number by a factor of two.

A factor of two. That is the entire between a and a very hole in a very planet.

The to hide

There is a strong , when something fails , to make the story about the . To let the be — something that happened to us.

I want to refuse that , because what actually happened is far more . What happened is that a died .

What a clean death gives you

In , most ideas are wrong. That is not a crisis, it is the . The thing is not being right often — it is being wrong in a way that leaves you knowing more than you did before.

Our was clean. It told us, , which link in the chain was weak, on which day, under which . That is now in the hands of every team the next . In a very real sense, the lander at its most job: it a wrong answer, , for everyone.

Let people grieve the

One more thing, and it is the part nobody puts in press .

We built that for six years. People for it. Someone to weld for it. When it stopped , the room went silent for eleven seconds — I timed it.

We let that happen. We did not start the retro. And I think that , because teams that are not to grieve a start hiding the small ones, and the small hidden ones are how the big ones get built.

The ask

So: when something of yours fails, ask two questions. What did this ? And who needs to be to feel bad about it for a few quiet seconds before we get back to work?

❧